Skip to content
Fort Union

Guide · North Dakota and Montana

Montana vs. North Dakota mineral rules: what's different for a royalty owner

The Bakken doesn't stop at the state line, but the law does. If your minerals, or a relative's, sit in Montana instead of North Dakota, the check can come on a different clock, the pooling penalty reads differently and the taxes don't match. Here's a side-by-side of the rules we've read, with a link to our full guide on each.

Last reviewed:

Which state's rules apply

The rules that apply are the ones for the state where the well and the minerals sit, not where you live. Montana's royalty withholding guide, for example, applies to every type of royalty owner receiving royalties on Montana production.[1] If you own on both sides of the line, you can end up with two payment deadlines, two tax setups and two sets of stub rules in the same mailbox.

Federal and tribal minerals have their own rules in places, as our taxes guide points out. This page sticks to privately owned minerals.

When the check is due, and interest if it's late

North Dakota gives the operator 150 days after the oil or gas is marketed. After that, the operator owes interest on the unpaid royalty at 18 percent a year, and the owner doesn't have to ask for it.[2]

Montana's clock is tighter once a well is producing. The first royalty is due within 120 days after the initial oil or gas from the lease is marketed, and after that within 60 days for oil and 90 days for gas.[3] Late royalty bears interest at the maximum rate under section 31-1-107, which is the greater of 15 percent a year or 6 percentage points over the bank prime rate.[3] So a late Montana payment earns at least 15 percent, and North Dakota's is a flat 18.

The two statutes share a few things. Both let the operator hold tiny amounts: North Dakota allows semiannual payment when the total is under $50, and Montana allows semiannual payment under $50 and annual payment under $10.[2], [3] Both turn off the interest rule if you take your share of production in kind or if there's a title dispute that would change who gets paid. North Dakota adds an owner who can't be located after reasonable inquiry.[2], [3] In both states the court in the county where the well sits hears the case, and the winner recovers costs and reasonable attorney's fees.[2], [3] North Dakota's section also says breach of the royalty obligation may be grounds for cancelling the lease, if a court decides the equities call for it.[2]

More on each side: our royalty check deductions guide and our guide to Montana royalty payment law.

What the check stub has to show

North Dakota's statute says the statement with your payment has to let you identify the amount of oil or gas sold and each deduction.[4] The Commission's rule fills in the list: the lease, property or well name, the month and year of the sales, your interest as a decimal, the amount and purpose of each deduction, and an address for questions. It also calls for the total state severance and other production taxes, and your share of the total sales value before tax deductions.[5]

Montana's list is its own. Every payment has to come with your name, the payment date and any owner number, the months of production and any lease number, the type of product and the barrels or cubic feet you're paid on, the amount and type of each tax withheld, the net value of production and your net value, and contact information. Each charge against you has to be its own line item, and knowingly leaving the information off can be a misdemeanor with a fine up to $1,000.[6]

Division orders

Both states say a division order can't change your lease. In North Dakota, one that varies the lease is invalid to the extent of the variance, and the lease terms take precedence.[2] In Montana, a division order may not alter or amend the lease and doesn't relieve the lessee of any lease obligation.[7]

North Dakota adds a line Montana's section doesn't have: royalty payments may not be withheld because you haven't signed one.[2] Montana, for its part, spells out what a division order has to contain, including the name, address and tax identification number of each owner paid and a provision requiring notice when ownership changes.[7] Our division order guide covers what to check before you sign either kind.

Pooling and the risk penalty

Both states pool unleased and unwilling owners by order, after a hearing, on terms the statutes call just and reasonable.[8], [9] The penalty for not joining a well is where they read differently.

In North Dakota, an owner who elects not to take part can be charged actual costs plus a risk penalty of 200 percent of the owner's share of reasonable drilling and completion costs when the interest is leased, and 50 percent when it isn't. The penalty comes only out of production from the pooled unit, and the owner paying has to have made a good-faith attempt to get an unleased owner to lease or a leased owner to join. An unleased interest pooled after July 31, 2009 is entitled to a cost-free royalty equal to the acreage-weighted average royalty of the leased tracts in the unit or, at the operator's election, 16 percent.[8]

In Montana, the order has to charge a refusing owner 200 percent of that owner's share of the costs of staking, site preparation, rights-of-way, drilling, testing and completing the well and of the equipment in the well, plus 100 percent of the share of new surface equipment and of operating costs until the agreeing owners recover their money. The section doesn't set a lower percentage for unleased owners. Instead, a refusing owner with no lease is treated as owning a landowner royalty of one-eighth of the owner's share of production until the costs are recovered.[9]

The notice clock is the same in both: 30 days to elect. Montana presumes you refused if you don't pay or agree in writing after notice by certified mail to your address of record in the county or on file with the board.[9] North Dakota's rule requires a written invitation with itemized estimated costs, served personally or by mail or courier with a signed receipt.[10] Our guide to spacing units and pooling goes through the North Dakota side. If an invitation lands in your mailbox from either state, take it to an attorney or an oil and gas accountant right away. The dollars can be large and the deadline is short.

Production taxes and withholding

North Dakota charges two taxes on oil: 5 percent gross production tax and 5 percent extraction tax, so 10 percent of gross value for oil that isn't exempt. The state says the gross production tax attaches to the whole production, royalty interest included.[11]

Montana's Department of Revenue lists 15.10 percent for nonworking interest owners, a category that includes royalty owners.[12] Montana also withholds state income tax from royalty payments on Montana production. Under a 2025 law the withholding rate follows the top marginal income tax rate: 5.9 percent in 2025, 5.65 percent in 2026 and 5.4 percent in 2027.[13]

Don't line up 10 against 15.1 and call it a draw. Each state defines the value it taxes in its own way, and both carve out exemptions and reduced rates. Our taxes guide goes through them, and the royalty estimator lets you test your own numbers.

Dormant minerals

North Dakota has a dormant mineral law. A mineral interest that goes unused for 20 years before the first publication of the required notice is deemed abandoned, and title moves to the surface owner, unless a statement of claim has been recorded.[14] The statute lists what counts as use, such as production, a recorded lease or a recorded pooling order. Our dormant mineral guide has the steps.

Montana State University Extension's guide says mineral ownership never lapses in Montana and that dormant mineral legislation hasn't passed.[15] That's one reason old family minerals on the Montana side can still be live decades later.

Jim's take

If you've got minerals in both states, I'd keep two folders, one per state, and not treat them as one. A late check in Montana and a late check in North Dakota run on different clocks, and the pooling letter that shows up for one of them won't read like the other. Read each letter with the state it came from in mind, and check the deadline in it against the statute before you assume the operator has it right.

Jim Fort, Fort Union Minerals

A note on our interest

Fort Union buys minerals and royalty interests, so we have a commercial interest in this subject. Nothing in this guide depends on selling to us, and each statement comes from a public source listed below. Our editorial standards explain how we source and review our pages. If you ever want to know what we'd pay for your interest, the offer page is the way to reach us.

Sources

These are the sources behind this guide, in the order we first cite them. We read each of these between October 25 and November 4, 2026.

  1. Montana Mineral Royalty Withholding Tax Guide (V2, March 2025) — Montana Department of Revenue, read October 25, 2026.
  2. N.D.C.C. chapter 47-16, Leases (sections 47-16-30, 47-16-36 to 47-16-41 and 47-16-39.1 to 47-16-39.3) — North Dakota Legislative Branch, Century Code, read October 25, 2026.
  3. MCA 82-10-103, Obligation to pay royalties as essence of contract, interest — Montana Legislature, Montana Code Annotated 2025, read October 30, 2026.
  4. N.D.C.C. section 38-08-06.3, information statement to accompany payment to royalty owner — North Dakota Legislative Branch, Century Code chapter 38-08, read October 25, 2026.
  5. N.D.A.C. chapter 43-02-06, Royalty Statements — North Dakota Legislative Branch (Administrative Code), read October 25, 2026.
  6. MCA 82-10-104, Payment of royalties, form of record required — Montana Legislature, Montana Code Annotated 2025, read October 30, 2026.
  7. MCA 82-10-110, Division order, definition and effect — Montana Legislature, Montana Code Annotated 2025, read October 30, 2026.
  8. N.D.C.C. chapter 38-08, Control of Oil and Gas Resources (sections 38-08-04, 38-08-07, 38-08-08, 38-08-10, 38-08-13 and 38-08-14) — North Dakota Legislative Branch, Century Code, parts read October 25, 2026.
  9. MCA 82-11-202, Pooling of interest within spacing unit — Montana Legislature, Montana Code Annotated 2025, read November 4, 2026. Subsection (2) sets the cost recovery and penalty for a refusing owner; subsection (3) covers notice.
  10. N.D.A.C. chapter 43-02-03, Rules of Practice (sections 43-02-03-01, 43-02-03-16.3 and 43-02-03-18) — North Dakota Legislative Branch (Administrative Code), parts read October 25, 2026.
  11. Oil and Gas Severance Tax — North Dakota Office of State Tax Commissioner, page read October 25, 2026.
  12. Oil and Natural Gas Production Tax — Montana Department of Revenue, page read October 25, 2026.
  13. Montana Employer and Information Agent Guide (V4, November 2025) — Montana Department of Revenue, read October 25, 2026.
  14. N.D.C.C. chapter 38-18.1, Termination of Mineral Interest — North Dakota Legislative Branch, Century Code, read October 25, 2026.
  15. Understanding Mineral Rights (MontGuide) — Montana State University Extension, viewed October 25, 2026.

This guide is general information from public sources. It isn't legal or tax advice. For your own lease, title or check, talk to a North Dakota attorney.

← When the operator changesWorking interest vs royalty →