Skip to content
Fort Union

Guide · Working interest and royalty

Working interest vs royalty interest: what heirs need to know

A relative leaves you "minerals," a division order shows up, and the paperwork starts talking about working interest and royalty. Those are not the same thing. One pays the bills to drill. The other gets a share of production without those costs. Here's how the difference reads in the sources we've checked.

Last reviewed:

The short version

A royalty interest is a share of oil or gas production that does not have to pay the drilling and operating costs. Montana State University Extension's leasing guide puts it the way most leases work: the mineral owner usually keeps a royalty interest in the production, if it occurs, and is paid for a fraction of that production.[1]

A working interest, sometimes called an operating or cost-bearing interest, is the share that pays those costs. The NDSU leasing bulletin, hosted by the Department of Mineral Resources, describes the company's share of production as the working interest and says the landowner's royalty, and any overriding royalty, are generally free from the costs of the company's operations.[2]

If you inherited a royalty under a lease, you are usually in the first camp. If the deed, probate papers or a division order say you own a working interest, or an "unleased" interest that was pooled as cost-bearing, you may be in the second. The labels on the paper matter more than the word "minerals" in a will.

How a typical Bakken lease splits the barrel

When a mineral owner signs an oil and gas lease, the company gets the right to drill and produce. The owner keeps a royalty. Montana State's guide says the owner is paid for a fraction of production if it occurs, and that terms are negotiable.[1] North Dakota's NDSU bulletin walks through the royalty clause in the same spirit: the landowner's royalty is generally free from the company's operating costs, while the working interest is the company's share.[2]

That split is why a royalty check can arrive without a bill for the rig. The lessee, or whoever holds the working interest, pays to drill, complete and operate. Your royalty decimal is your share of the production that the payor applies after the lease and the division of interest. Our division order guide shows how that decimal is usually built, and the royalty estimator lets you test your own numbers.

An overriding royalty is related but different. The NDSU bulletin says an overriding royalty is paid from the company's share of production, is usually free of the company's operating costs, and can also be reserved when someone farms out a lease.[2] If a division order lists an ORRI next to your name, that is not the same as the mineral royalty reserved in the lease, even though both are cost-free in the usual case. Our lease bonus and royalty guide covers the lease side.

What changes if the minerals were never leased

Unleased minerals sit in a different spot. North Dakota's pooling statute says that when the Industrial Commission pools a spacing unit, an unleased mineral interest pooled after July 31, 2009 is entitled to a cost-free royalty equal to the acreage-weighted average royalty of the leased tracts in the unit, or, at the operator's election, a cost-free royalty of sixteen percent. The remainder of the unleased interest is treated as a lessee or cost-bearing interest.[3]

In plain terms, an unleased owner who gets pooled can end up with a royalty piece and a working-interest piece on the same acres. The cost-bearing piece is where the risk penalty can attach if that owner elects not to join the well. Our guide to spacing units and pooling goes through the invitation, the 200 percent and 50 percent risk penalties, and the notice rules. This page is only flagging that "I never signed a lease" does not always mean "I only have a royalty."

How the tax forms draw the same line

The IRS draws a similar line on the tax return. Publication 525 says royalties from oil, gas and mineral properties are taxable as ordinary income, and that in most cases you report royalties on Schedule E (Form 1040). It then says that if you hold an operating oil, gas or mineral interest, you report the income and expenses on Schedule C (Form 1040).[4]

The same publication describes oil, gas and mineral royalty income as the amount you receive when natural resources are extracted from your property, generally based on production or revenue and paid by the person or company that leases the property from you.[4] That matches the lease picture above. The Schedule E instructions also note that if you have an economic interest in mineral property you may be able to deduct depletion.[5]

We are not giving tax advice. A CPA who has seen your division order and your 1099 can tell you which schedule fits. The point for an heir is simpler: royalty and working interest do not land on the same form, and the IRS treats an "operating" interest differently from a leased royalty.

What North Dakota requires on the royalty side

Once you are being paid as a royalty owner, North Dakota has its own payment and stub rules. The Department of Mineral Resources' mineral owner page points to N.D.C.C. 47-16-39.1 for the obligation to pay royalty interest owners from a producing well, including interest on late payments, and to N.D.C.C. 38-08-06.3 and the Royalty Statement Rules in N.D.A.C. 43-02-06 for what has to accompany the check.[6], [7], [8], [9]

Those rules are written for royalty owners. They are one more clue on a stub or a division order: if the payor is sending you a royalty information statement under chapter 43-02-06, it is treating you as a royalty owner for that payment. Our royalty check deductions guide walks through the stub line by line.

If the interest came through an estate, start with the deed and the probate papers, not the well name on the check. Our inherited minerals guide covers the recording and probate steps, and do I own minerals covers how to check county records when the paperwork is thin.

How to tell which one you have

  1. Read the deed, mineral deed or personal representative's deed that put the interest in your name. Look for words like "royalty," "non-participating royalty," "overriding royalty," "working interest," "oil and gas leasehold" or "executive rights."
  2. Read the oil and gas lease, if there is one. A leased mineral owner usually keeps a royalty; the lessee holds the working interest.[1], [2]
  3. Read the division order or transfer order. It should show your decimal and often a type of interest. Compare that decimal to the one on the last stub.[9]
  4. If the minerals were unleased when a well was drilled, read the pooling order for the spacing unit. The statute's cost-free royalty and cost-bearing remainder language is what the order is applying.[3]
  5. If the papers still disagree, take the deed, the lease, the division order and a recent stub to an oil and gas attorney or a landman who does title. DMR says it does not review private lease information or private contracts.[6]

None of those steps requires selling anything. They are how you find out what you actually inherited before you answer a buyer's letter or sign a new division order.

Jim's take

When someone calls and says they inherited minerals, the first thing I ask is whether there's a lease and what the division order calls the interest. "Minerals" in a will can mean a royalty under someone else's lease, a working interest that still owes costs, or both after a pooling order. The word on the deed and the decimal on the stub tell you more than the well name on the check.

Jim Fort, Fort Union Minerals

A note on our interest

Fort Union buys minerals and royalty interests, so we have a commercial interest in this subject. Nothing in this guide depends on selling to us, and each statement comes from a public source listed below. Our editorial standards explain how we source and review our pages. If you ever want to know what we'd pay for your interest, the offer page is the way to reach us.

Sources

These are the sources behind this guide, in the order we first cite them. We read each of these on November 5, 2026, or confirmed the same text we had already read.

  1. Oil and Gas Leasing, MontGuide MT201209AG (reviewed January 2017) — Montana State University Extension, read October 25, 2026.
  2. North Dakota Oil and Gas Leasing Considerations, Extension Bulletin 29 (revised October 2006) — North Dakota State University Extension, hosted by the North Dakota Department of Mineral Resources, read October 25, 2026.
  3. N.D.C.C. chapter 38-08, Control of Oil and Gas Resources (sections 38-08-04, 38-08-07, 38-08-08, 38-08-10, 38-08-13 and 38-08-14) — North Dakota Legislative Branch, Century Code, parts read October 25, 2026.
  4. Publication 525, Taxable and Nontaxable Income (Royalties; Oil, gas, and minerals) — Internal Revenue Service, read November 5, 2026. States that oil, gas and mineral royalties are ordinary income usually reported on Schedule E, and that an operating oil, gas or mineral interest is reported on Schedule C.
  5. 2025 Instructions for Schedule E (Form 1040) — Internal Revenue Service, read October 25, 2026.
  6. Mineral Owner information and frequently asked questions — North Dakota Department of Mineral Resources, Oil and Gas Division, viewed October 25, 2026.
  7. N.D.C.C. chapter 47-16, Leases (sections 47-16-30, 47-16-36 to 47-16-41 and 47-16-39.1 to 47-16-39.3) — North Dakota Legislative Branch, Century Code, read October 25, 2026.
  8. N.D.C.C. section 38-08-06.3, information statement to accompany payment to royalty owner — North Dakota Legislative Branch, Century Code chapter 38-08, read October 25, 2026.
  9. N.D.A.C. chapter 43-02-06, Royalty Statements — North Dakota Legislative Branch (Administrative Code), read October 25, 2026.

This guide is general information from public sources. It isn't legal or tax advice. For your own lease, title or check, talk to a North Dakota attorney.

← Montana vs. North Dakota rulesNPRI and override royalty →