Guide · Pore space
Who owns the pore space under your North Dakota land
Landowners in North Dakota now get letters about pore space, from carbon dioxide storage projects and from disposal well operators. Mineral owners get some of the same notices and wonder whether any of it is theirs. The answer is in a short chapter of the Century Code, and it usually surprises people who own minerals but not the surface.
Last reviewed:
The short version
In North Dakota, pore space belongs to whoever owns the surface. Selling the surface sells the pore space with it, and since April 9, 2009 a deed that tries to keep the two apart is void as to the pore space.[1] If you own minerals only, you generally don't own the pore space. The mineral estate is still the dominant estate, though,[1] and a carbon dioxide storage permit doesn't stop a mineral owner or lessee from drilling through a storage reservoir under Commission rules.[2]
What pore space is
The statute defines pore space as a cavity or void, whether natural or artificially created, in a subsurface sedimentary stratum.[1] In plain terms, it's the tiny open space inside rock deep underground. Oil and gas sit in pore space before they're produced. Saltwater disposal wells push produced water into it, and carbon dioxide storage projects want it to hold CO2 for good. The carbon dioxide storage chapter uses the same definition.[2]
It goes with the surface, not the minerals
Chapter 47-31 is only a few sections long. Title to pore space in all strata under the land is vested in the owner of the overlying surface estate. A conveyance of the surface conveys the pore space under it. Title to pore space can't be severed from the surface, and an instrument that tries is void as to that severance. Leasing pore space is allowed and doesn't count as a severance.[1]
There's one exception for older paper. The chapter doesn't affect transactions before April 9, 2009 that severed pore space from the surface.[1] If your family's deeds from before then mention pore space, storage rights or subsurface strata, have someone read them closely.
So a mineral owner who sold the surface years ago, or inherited minerals without the land, usually has no pore space to lease. A surface owner who sells the farm should know the pore space goes with the land, and that a reservation of it in the deed won't hold.[1] Our guide on how to check whether you own minerals covers pulling the deed chain at the county recorder.
The mineral estate still comes first
The pore space chapter says it doesn't change the common law as of April 9, 2009 on the rights belonging to, or the dominance of, the mineral estate.[1] The storage chapter backs that up. Neither the chapter nor a storage permit prevents a mineral owner or lessee from drilling through or near a storage reservoir to explore for and develop minerals, as long as the drilling follows Commission rules that protect the reservoir.[2]
Before the Commission can issue a storage permit, it has to find whether the storage facility contains commercially valuable minerals. If it does, it can issue the permit only if it's satisfied the interests of the mineral owners or lessees won't be adversely affected or have been dealt with in an arrangement between them and the storage operator.[2]
How a carbon dioxide storage permit works
Geologic storage of carbon dioxide is allowed only with a permit from the Industrial Commission, and the Commission has to hold a public hearing first.[2] Notice is published for two consecutive weeks in the official newspaper of each county involved. It also goes by mail or tracked commercial delivery to each mineral lessee, mineral owner and pore space owner within the storage reservoir and within one-half mile of its boundaries, and to each surface owner over the reservoir and within that same half mile.[2] So a mineral owner near a project should get notice even though the pore space isn't theirs.
The rules add that the applicant's notice must say amalgamation of the reservoir's pore space is required, that the Commission may include nonconsenting owners' pore space, and that amalgamation will be considered at the hearing. Except in an emergency, the Commission gives at least a 30-day public notice and comment period on the draft permit.[3] Comments have to be in writing before the hearing or presented at it.[3] Our NDIC hearing notice guide explains how to read a docket and take part.
Among the findings the Commission must make before issuing the permit:
- the operator made a good-faith effort to get the consent of every pore space owner in the storage reservoir;
- the operator has the consent of owners of at least 60 percent of the reservoir's pore space;
- the carbon dioxide won't escape from the reservoir, and surface waters and fresh-water formations won't be adversely affected;
- the reservoir's horizontal and vertical boundaries are defined, with buffer areas; and
- all nonconsenting pore space owners are or will be equitably compensated.[2]
If the operator doesn't get everyone's consent, the Commission may require the nonconsenting owners' pore space to be included in the storage facility. That's what amalgamation means.[2] When a permit issues, the Commission files a certificate with the county recorder describing the area covered.[2]
In practice, the Division explains, North Dakota approves a storage facility permit first, through signed Commission orders that create the facility area, amalgamate the pore space and set financial responsibility. Those orders don't authorize injection. The operator still needs a Class VI well permit, and injection starts only after the well is completed, tested and approved.[4] North Dakota has run its own Class VI program since the EPA granted the state primacy on April 24, 2018.[4]
Who is responsible for the CO2, and for how long
The storage operator holds title to the injected carbon dioxide until the Commission issues a certificate of project completion, and while it holds title it's liable for any damage the carbon dioxide causes, including damage from CO2 that escapes.[2]
The certificate can't be issued until at least ten years after injection ends, and only after notice and a hearing. The operator has to show, among other things, that the CO2 has become stable, that pending claims have been addressed, and that wells have been plugged and the site reclaimed. Once it's issued, title to the facility and the stored CO2 passes to the state without compensation, and the operator and the companies that produced the CO2 are released from the regulatory requirements for the facility.[2]
Enhanced oil recovery is handled differently
The storage chapter doesn't apply to applications to use carbon dioxide for an enhanced oil or gas recovery project. Those go through the oil and gas conservation chapter, 38-08, the same chapter that governs spacing, pooling and unitization. The Commission can later allow an enhanced recovery project to be converted into a storage facility, and then the storage rules apply.[2] If a CO2 flood is proposed in a unit you own in, read our unitization guide first.
Saltwater disposal and the 2022 court decision
In 2019 the Legislature passed Senate Bill 2344. Among other things it said operators could use subsurface formations for disposal and other Commission-approved operations without the owner being able to prohibit it or demand payment, it defined "land" in the surface damage law to exclude pore space, and it added section 47-31-09, which said injection into pore space for disposal and similar operations isn't, by itself, trespass, nuisance or another tort.
On August 4, 2022, in Northwest Landowners Association v. State, 2022 ND 150, the North Dakota Supreme Court held that those parts of the bill were physical takings without just compensation and declared them unenforceable. The court struck the language in 38-08-25(5) that let operators use subsurface formations for disposal and "any other operation" under the chapter without the owner being able to object or demand payment, the definition of land that excluded pore space, and the part of 47-31-09(1) about disposal operations. It left the rest of the bill standing. The Century Code we read still prints section 47-31-09 in full,[1] so read it with that decision in mind.
For surface owners, the upshot is that the Legislature can't simply take away the right to be paid when pore space is used for saltwater disposal. Section 47-31-09 itself refers to contracts for use of the surface estate for disposal operations.[1] Our guide to surface damages covers the compensation law for drilling on your land.
If your land is in Montana
Montana handles it a little differently. Its oil and gas conservation law says a carbon dioxide injection permit doesn't take away property owners' rights that haven't been committed to a storage reservoir, and doesn't prevent mineral owners or lessees from drilling through or near one under board rules. If ownership of a geologic storage reservoir can't be determined from the deeds or severance documents, the law presumes the surface owner owns it.[5] That's a presumption, not North Dakota's flat rule, so the deed language matters more there. Our Montana vs North Dakota comparison covers the other differences.
Where the storage projects are so far
As of November 16, 2026, the storage facility permits listed on the Division's Class VI page are in Oliver, Mercer, Morton, McLean and Stark counties, most of them in the Broom Creek formation.[4] None are in the core Bakken counties we cover most often, but the Commission's notice rules are the same wherever a project goes.
A checklist if you get a pore space letter
- Figure out which estate you own. Pull your deed and any later conveyances. Pore space follows the surface unless it was severed before April 9, 2009.[1]
- If you own the surface, read any lease or easement offer for the formation it covers, the payment terms, how long it lasts and what happens at closure.
- If you own minerals only, check whether you're within the reservoir or the half-mile notice area, and watch the hearing docket for the case.[2]
- Read the draft permit and fact sheet, which the notice says you can get from the Commission, and send written comments before the hearing if you have concerns.[3]
- Look up the project's orders on the Division's Class VI page once they're signed.[4]
- Talk to a North Dakota attorney before signing anything that covers the subsurface.
Got a letter you can't make sense of? Send Jim a question at jim@fortunionminerals.com.
Jim's take
If you own minerals only and a storage notice shows up, don't read it as a check on the way. In North Dakota the pore space went with the surface, so unless an old deed split it off before 2009, it isn't yours to lease. What the notice does give you is a seat at the hearing, and the statute says the Commission has to look out for valuable minerals before it signs a permit. If you own both the surface and the minerals, keep the two conversations separate and read each offer on its own terms.
Jim Fort, Fort Union Minerals
A note on our interest
Fort Union buys minerals and royalty interests, so we have a commercial interest in this subject. Nothing in this guide depends on selling to us, and each statement comes from a public source listed below. Our editorial standards explain how we source and review our pages. If you ever want to know what we'd pay for your interest, the offer page is the way to reach us.
Sources
These are the sources behind this guide, in the order we first cite them. We read each statute, rule and page listed here on November 16, 2026.
- N.D.C.C. chapter 47-31, Subsurface Pore Space Policy (sections 47-31-01 through 47-31-09) — North Dakota Legislative Assembly, North Dakota Century Code, read November 16, 2026. Section 47-31-03 vests title to pore space in the surface owner; 47-31-04 and 47-31-05 tie it to surface conveyances and void attempts to sever it; 47-31-07 leaves severances made before April 9, 2009 alone; 47-31-08 keeps the mineral estate's common-law dominance.
- N.D.C.C. chapter 38-22, Carbon Dioxide Underground Storage — North Dakota Legislative Assembly, North Dakota Century Code, read November 16, 2026. Sections 38-22-06 (hearing notice), 38-22-08 (permit findings, including the 60 percent consent rule), 38-22-10 (amalgamation), 38-22-13 (preservation of rights), 38-22-16 and 38-22-17 (title, liability and the certificate of project completion), and 38-22-19 (enhanced recovery projects).
- N.D.A.C. chapter 43-05-01, Geologic Storage of Carbon Dioxide — North Dakota Legislative Branch (Administrative Code), read November 16, 2026. The storage facility permit notice rules, including the statement that amalgamation of pore space will be considered at the hearing.
- Class VI - Geologic Sequestration Wells — North Dakota Department of Mineral Resources, Oil and Gas Division, page read November 16, 2026. Primacy history, the storage facility permit process and the list of issued permits and orders.
- MCA 82-11-180, Preservation of property rights — Montana Legislature, Montana Code Annotated 2025, read November 16, 2026.
This guide is general information from public sources. It isn't legal or tax advice. For your own lease, title or check, talk to a North Dakota attorney.