Skip to content
Fort Union

Guide · Federal minerals

Communitization agreements: when your North Dakota spacing unit includes federal minerals

Western North Dakota is a patchwork. A 1,280- or 2,560-acre spacing unit can take in private minerals, state minerals, a few federal tracts and, on Fort Berthold, Indian trust minerals. The Industrial Commission's spacing and pooling orders handle most of that. Federal and Indian minerals need one more piece of paper, a communitization agreement, and it's the reason you'll sometimes see a well name with "Federal" in it or a letter asking you to ratify something called a CA.

Last reviewed:

The short version

A communitization agreement, or CA, pools a federal lease with other lands in a spacing unit when the federal tract can't be developed on its own under the established spacing program. Once the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) approves it, production from the unit counts as production on each lease committed to it, and the unit's oil and gas are split among the tracts.[1]

For a private mineral owner, a CA usually changes less than people fear. Your royalty is still paid under your own lease. What the CA mostly affects is timing and paperwork: when the federal share is settled, and whether the operator asks you to sign a ratification.

Why federal minerals need a separate agreement

North Dakota's spacing and pooling orders come from the Industrial Commission. Federal minerals are managed by the Bureau of Land Management, and BLM doesn't treat a state order as committing federal land by itself. The federal rule lets BLM approve a CA when a lease, or part of one, can't be independently developed under an established well-spacing or well-development program, and only after BLM decides it's in the public interest.[1]

BLM's manual says the operator generally still has to submit a CA for approval even when the state has force-pooled the unit, and that if BLM decides a state spacing or pooling order isn't in the public interest, federal lands won't be made subject to it unless the problem is resolved with the state.[2]

In Montana and the Dakotas, BLM's Miles City Field Office processes Montana CAs and the North Dakota Field Office in Dickinson handles North Dakota federal CAs. CAs that involve Indian minerals go through the Bureau of Indian Affairs, including its Fort Berthold Agency for Fort Berthold minerals.[3]

What the agreement says

The rule sets out the minimum. A CA has to describe the separate tracts in the drilling or spacing unit, show how production or royalties are apportioned among them, name the operator, and protect the interests of the United States. It has to be signed by or on behalf of all necessary parties.[1] The application includes an Exhibit A map of the area and the tracts and an Exhibit B showing the tracts and their ownership.[1]

The manual says the tract allocation is based on surface acreage.[2] In practice that means each tract's share of unit production is its acres divided by the total acres in the unit, the same basic arithmetic the state uses for a pooled unit. Our guide to spacing units and pooling walks through how that math reaches your decimal.

The CA has to be filed before the federal lease involved expires if that lease is going to get the benefit of it.[1] That's one reason operators chase these agreements early.

When a CA takes effect and how long it lasts

An approved CA is effective from the date of the agreement or the date production starts from the communitized formation, whichever comes first. The exception is a unit force-pooled by a state order after the date of first sale; then the CA's effective date is the order's effective date.[1]

BLM asks for the application at least 90 calendar days before first production, so royalty reporting to the federal government is accurate from the start.[1] If approval comes after the well is already producing, the effective date still reaches back to the earlier of those two dates.

Once approved, a CA runs for two years from the effective date or the approval date, whichever is later, and as long after that as communitized substances can be produced in paying quantities, unless the agreement says otherwise.[1]

Do private royalty owners have to sign?

Not always. BLM's manual says non-federal royalty owners must do one of three things: sign the agreement, be force-pooled by a state order, or have signed a lease that already contains a pooling provision. It also lets BLM approve a CA that's complete except for some working interest and royalty owner signatures, as long as a state order force-pooling those interests is submitted with it.[2]

Many Bakken leases have a pooling clause, and many units are covered by an Industrial Commission pooling order, so plenty of owners never sign anything. If you get a ratification from an operator, it's usually because your lease is old, the pooling clause is narrow, or the operator wants a clean signature from every party. Read it before you sign. A ratification shouldn't change your royalty rate or add any deductions. If it does, that's a separate deal and you should treat it like one.

Unleased federal tracts and escrow

Sometimes a federal tract in the unit hasn't been leased yet. The manual says BLM can generally still approve a CA when at least one leased tract in the area has a producible well and leasing the federal land would take more than six months.[2]

In that case the operator has to put the proceeds for the unleased tract into an escrow account, the unleased federal land should be offered at a competitive lease sale as soon as possible, and whoever wins it has to join the CA before the escrowed money is paid out.[2] That's one of the ways parcels end up on the BLM Montana-Dakotas sale list. Our lease sales calendar tracks the upcoming sales.

None of that escrow applies to your own fee tract. Your share is still owed under your lease.

Indian minerals and Fort Berthold

When a spacing unit includes Indian trust minerals, the Bureau of Indian Affairs approves the CA, and a unit with both federal and Indian minerals needs joint approval from BLM and BIA.[2] The manual notes that tribal approval is required before communitization. A pooling clause in the lease can supply it, but not every Indian lease has one, and without it the operator has to show the tribe's approval before BIA will sign off. It also says that, unlike federal leases, Indian leases have no provision for extensions when a CA terminates.[2]

If you own fee minerals inside the Fort Berthold Reservation, expect that some of the units you're in will have Indian CAs. That can mean a longer wait for the trust tracts to be settled, but it doesn't change the fee owners' lease terms.

What it means for your royalty check

Your lease still controls your royalty rate and deductions. The CA decides how unit production is divided among the tracts, and your share follows from your tract's allocation and your interest in that tract.[1]

North Dakota's royalty statute still applies to the operator's duty to pay you. If royalties aren't paid within 150 days after the oil or gas is marketed, the operator owes interest at 18 percent a year without you having to ask. The statute's listed exceptions are owners who take their oil in kind, title disputes that affect distribution, and owners who can't be located after reasonable inquiry.[4] A pending federal approval isn't one of the listed exceptions. If your payments are being held and the reason given is "waiting on the CA," ask the operator in writing which part of the unit is actually in suspense and why yours is included.

A new CA or a revised one can also change your decimal, because the tract allocation is set by the agreement. Our division order guide explains how to check a new decimal against your acres.

What to pull together

  1. The Industrial Commission spacing and pooling orders for your unit. The case and order numbers are in the well file on the state's well search.
  2. Your oil and gas lease, and especially its pooling clause.
  3. Any ratification, joinder or CA exhibit the operator sent you. Exhibit B is the one that shows the tracts and their ownership.[1]
  4. Your division order and the last few royalty statements, so you can compare the decimal with your tract's acres.
  5. If the unit includes federal acreage, note the well's first production date. The CA's effective date is tied to it or to the agreement date.[1]

If something still doesn't add up, the operator's owner relations department is the first call. For questions about a federal CA itself, the BLM Montana-Dakotas communitization page lists the office that handles it.[3]

Jim's take

The CA itself almost never hurts a private owner. The delay can. When I see a unit with a federal tract, I check the first production date and the CA's effective date against when the owner's checks actually started. If there's a gap of more than 150 days on a fee tract with clean title, the statute's interest provision is worth bringing up with the operator, politely and in writing.

Jim Fort, Fort Union Minerals

A note on our interest

Fort Union buys minerals and royalty interests, so we have a commercial interest in this subject. Nothing in this guide depends on selling to us, and each statement comes from a public source listed below. Our editorial standards explain how we source and review our pages. If you ever want to know what we'd pay for your interest, the offer page is the way to reach us.

Sources

These are the sources behind this guide, in the order we first cite them. We read the federal rule, the BLM manual and the BLM Montana-Dakotas page listed here on November 20, 2026, along with the North Dakota royalty statute.

  1. 43 CFR part 3100, subpart 3105, Cooperative Conservation Provisions (sections 3105.21 to 3105.24, communitization agreements) — Electronic Code of Federal Regulations (eCFR), Current text read November 20, 2026.
  2. BLM Manual 3160-9, Communitization (Release 3-215, July 7, 1988) — Bureau of Land Management, Read November 20, 2026. Sections .11C (agreement contents), .11D (approval and effective dates), .11F (effects of state orders), .11H (unleased tracts) and .2 (Indian lands). The manual cites the older 43 CFR 3105.2-x section numbers; the current rule is 3105.21 to 3105.24.
  3. Communitization in Montana-Dakotas — Bureau of Land Management, Page read November 20, 2026.
  4. N.D.C.C. chapter 47-16, Leases (sections 47-16-30, 47-16-36 to 47-16-41 and 47-16-39.1 to 47-16-39.3) — North Dakota Legislative Branch, Century Code, read October 25, 2026.

This guide is general information from public sources. It isn't legal or tax advice. For your own lease, title or check, talk to a North Dakota attorney.

← Life estates and royaltiesLease sales calendar →