Guide · Family and estates
Life estates in North Dakota minerals: who gets the royalties?
Parents deed their minerals to the kids but keep a life estate, or a will leaves them to a surviving spouse for life and then to the children. It's a common setup in western North Dakota, and it works fine until the first royalty check or lease bonus shows up and the family isn't sure whose money it is. The state Supreme Court answered part of that question in 2020. Here's what it said and what it didn't.
Last reviewed:
The short version
A life tenant holds the minerals for as long as they live. The remainderman gets them after that. Under North Dakota law the life tenant can use the property like an owner, but can't do anything that injures the inheritance.[1] Pulling oil out of the ground normally counts as that kind of injury, because it uses up what the remainderman will eventually own.[2]
There's an important exception. If a lease was already in place and a well was already producing when the life estate was created, the life tenant gets the royalties and bonus payments and doesn't have to hold them for the remainderman, unless the deed or will says otherwise. That's the open mines doctrine, and the North Dakota Supreme Court adopted it in Reese v. Reese-Young in 2020.[2]
If there was no lease or no production when the life estate began, the Supreme Court left that situation open in Reese, so the answer isn't settled. Minerals held in a trust follow a different rule altogether, set by statute.[3]
Life tenant and remainderman, in plain terms
A life estate can be created a few ways. The most common one we see is a deed where the owners convey their minerals to a child and reserve a life estate for themselves. A will can do the same thing by leaving minerals to a spouse for life with the remainder to the children. Either way, two people or groups now hold an interest in the same acres at the same time.
The statute gives the life tenant broad use of the property, the same as a fee owner, with one limit: no act to the injury of the inheritance.[1] The life tenant also has to pay the taxes and other annual charges on the property.[1] The remainderman, for their part, can sue for an injury done to the inheritance even while the life estate is still running.[4]
Oil and gas sit awkwardly with those rules. Most property can be used for a lifetime and handed on. Minerals get used up as they're produced. The Supreme Court said that as a general matter, a life tenant who takes minerals and keeps the royalties is consuming the corpus and lowering the value of the remainder, which amounts to waste unless the document creating the life estate expressly gives the life tenant that privilege.[2]
The open mines doctrine and Reese v. Reese-Young
The open mines doctrine is the old common-law exception to that rule. If the land was already being used to extract and sell oil, gas or other minerals before the life estate was created, the life tenant may keep doing so and keep the proceeds, even though it lowers the value of the remainder. The court traced it to section 144 of the Restatement (First) of Property and noted that the person who creates a life estate can shut the doctrine off by saying so in the deed or will.[2]
The facts in Reese were simple and typical. An oil and gas lease covering Mountrail County minerals was signed in January 2005, and oil and gas were being produced by November 2007. In July 2008 a married couple quitclaimed their 12.5 percent mineral interest to a family member and reserved a life estate for both of their lives. The husband died that September. Years later the surviving wife and the remainderman went to court over who was entitled to the royalties.[2]
The district court ruled the open mines doctrine wasn't North Dakota law and ordered the life tenant to hold the royalty proceeds in trust for the remainderman, keeping only the interest earned on them. The Supreme Court reversed. It held that the common law applies where no statute conflicts with it, that neither section 47-02-33 nor section 47-04-22 says how lease payments are split between a life tenant and a remainderman, and that the open mines doctrine is part of North Dakota law.[2]
Because the lease and production came first and the deed didn't exclude the doctrine, the court held the life tenant was entitled to the production proceeds, including royalties and bonus payments, and didn't have to hold them in trust for the remainderman.[2] The court also pointed out that the deed reserved only the minerals, not the surface, and said a life estate in minerals alone would be close to worthless without the doctrine.[2]
What the court didn't decide
One justice wrote separately to warn against reading the case too broadly. His concurrence is limited to these facts: the owner leased the minerals and production started before the remainder interest was created. He said he was less than certain the doctrine would apply if any material fact were different, and he reserved judgment on two situations in particular: a conveyance to the remainderman that includes both the surface and the minerals, and a lease the life tenant signs after the remainderman's title has vested.[2]
That second situation is common. Plenty of family life estates were set up on unleased or long-expired acreage, and the first Bakken lease came along years later. For those, the general rule the court described points toward the remainderman's side, since production that started after the life estate isn't an open mine. But the court didn't rule on that, so how the money gets split in a case like that is a question for a North Dakota attorney who has read the deed.
This is also why operators and lessees tend to want everyone with an interest to sign. A lease signed by the life tenant alone may not bind the remainderman, and nobody wants to drill on a lease that can be challenged later.
Minerals in a trust are handled differently
If the minerals are held in a trust with one person getting the income and others getting what's left later, the Uniform Principal and Income Act tells the trustee how to divide what comes in. The Reese opinion drew that same line: section 59-04.2-19 governs a trustee, not a life estate created by deed.[2]
- A royalty, shut-in payment, take-or-pay payment, bonus or delay rental that is more than nominal: 15 percent goes to principal and the rest to income.[3]
- A nominal delay rental or nominal annual rent: all income.[3]
- A working interest or any other interest not listed: 15 percent of the net amount goes to principal and the rest to income.[3]
The statute has transition rules for trusts that already received mineral money before August 1, 2015, and it lets a trustee petition the court to change the allocation permanently, considering things like the trust's purpose, the settlor's intent and the beneficiaries' circumstances.[3] If your family's minerals are in a trust, the trust document and the trustee's accounting are where to start.
What to pull together
- The recorded deed or the will that created the life estate. Read it for any language about royalties, bonuses, leasing or the open mines doctrine.
- The date the life estate began: the deed's date, or for a will, the date of death.
- The oil and gas lease covering the tract, and its date. Your county recorder has it.
- The first production date for each well in the spacing unit. DMR's well search shows it.
- Your division order and royalty statements, to see who the operator is actually paying now. Our division order guide explains what those documents say.
If the lease and production both came before the life estate, Reese is the case on point. If they came after, or the deed covers surface and minerals together, get an attorney's opinion before anyone signs a new lease or the family divides money that's been held in suspense.
When the life tenant dies, the remainderman's interest takes over. Expect the operator to ask for a certified death certificate before it changes the pay records, and check the recorded documents in each county where the minerals sit. Our guides on inherited minerals and transfer-on-death deeds cover related paperwork.
Jim's take
When a family sends me a life estate deed, the first thing I do is put three dates side by side: the deed, the lease and first production. In Reese the lease came in 2005 and production by 2007, both before the 2008 deed, and that order decided the case. If your dates line up the other way, don't assume Reese settles it for you. Get the deed in front of an attorney before the money starts getting split.
Jim Fort, Fort Union Minerals
A note on our interest
Fort Union buys minerals and royalty interests, so we have a commercial interest in this subject. Nothing in this guide depends on selling to us, and each statement comes from a public source listed below. Our editorial standards explain how we source and review our pages. If you ever want to know what we'd pay for your interest, the offer page is the way to reach us.
Sources
These are the sources behind this guide, in the order we first cite them. We read each statute and the opinion listed here on November 19, 2026.
- N.D.C.C. chapter 47-02, Estates in real property (sections 47-02-33 and 47-02-34) — North Dakota Legislative Assembly, North Dakota Century Code, read November 19, 2026.
- Reese v. Reese-Young, 2020 ND 35 (North Dakota Supreme Court, filed February 12, 2020) — North Dakota Supreme Court (opinion PDF via Justia), Opinion and special concurrence read November 19, 2026. Paragraphs 3 (facts), 12 to 18 (life estates, waste, Restatement section 144), 23 to 25 (holding) and 28 to 29 (Justice Crothers, specially concurring).
- N.D.C.C. chapter 59-04.2, Uniform Principal and Income Act (section 59-04.2-19, minerals, water and other natural resources) — North Dakota Legislative Assembly, North Dakota Century Code, read November 19, 2026.
- N.D.C.C. chapter 47-04, Rights and incidents of ownership in real property (section 47-04-22) — North Dakota Legislative Assembly, North Dakota Century Code, read November 19, 2026.
This guide is general information from public sources. It isn't legal or tax advice. For your own lease, title or check, talk to a North Dakota attorney.